Rising to—and beyond—the Peter Principle
Picture this: You’ve been promoted. The title’s shiny, the LinkedIn post is blowing up, and your family finally understands what you do. But a week in, you’re staring at your to-do list thinking, “Wait… they expect me to know how to do this?”
Welcome to the Peter Principle.
It’s that awkward moment when you realize you’ve been handed a high-stakes role, but the instructions are written in invisible ink. It’s like being promoted from sous chef to head chef—but suddenly, you’re cooking a 10-course meal blindfolded, with customers Yelp-reviewing your every move.
But here’s the thing: this isn’t just about individuals feeling like they’re navigating seven seas at once. It’s also about the organizations that expect them to stay afloat amidst stormy waters.
Leadership is about ownership, yes—but ownership in a system that doesn’t support growth? That’s an uphill battle where the hill is greased.
A leadership lens on the Peter Principle
For individual leaders: charting the course while building the ship
Owning your growth means:
Embracing public “incompetence” as a rite of passage: Every leader has a phase where they feel like a fish trying to climb a tree. Own it. Growth is awkward, and that’s okay.
Learning as you go—loudly: Ask questions. Admit mistakes. The best leaders aren’t the ones who know everything—they’re the ones who know how to learn anything.
Finding your mentors (& cheerleaders): Leadership isn’t a solo act. Build a network of people who see your potential and aren’t afraid to call out your blind spots.
Bottom line: Leadership is messy. Own the mess. It’s how you grow.
For Organizations: building the ship while leaders navigate stormy seas
If you want leaders to thrive, you need to:
Invest in growth before it’s a problem: Don’t wait for someone to hit their limit before offering support. Proactively create training, coaching, and mentorship opportunities.
Rethink promotion paths: Not everyone is destined for management, and that’s okay. Build parallel tracks that honor expertise without forcing people into roles they’re not built for.
Normalize mistakes as learning opportunities: Create a culture where leaders can try, fail, and try again—without fear of being benched for every misstep.
Bottom line: If the system isn’t built for growth, you’re setting people up to fail. Build better ladders.
--
The Peter Principle isn’t a sentence—it’s a Challenge
The Peter Principle can feel like an unavoidable law of leadership physics. But it doesn’t have to be.
For leaders, the challenge is to rise—not by pretending to have it all figured out, but by daring to grow, fail, and grow again. For organizations, the challenge is to create a system where that growth isn’t a Herculean effort but a natural part of the journey.
A metaphor for the road
Think of leadership growth like navigating seven simultaneous seas: unpredictable, demanding, and often overwhelming. But with each wave you ride, you gain strength—and eventually, the horizon becomes clearer.
So, what’s one step you’ll take today? Will you own your growth—or create space for someone else to thrive?
P.S. Even the most seasoned sailors have moments when the seas feel uncharted. Embrace the journey—every storm leads to calmer waters.
---